Phenomenological Approximation to Newton's Cradle
Phenomenological Approximation to Newton's Cradle
"Newton's cradle" (never actually mentioned by Newton himself) is an iconic executive desk toy consisting of five identical polished steel balls aligned with one another, each suspended from a frame a by pair of thin wires. When a ball at one end of the line is pulled back and released, it collides with the middle three balls, which remain stationary, while the ball at the other end of the line swings out to mirror the motion of the first ball. Then the motion reverses itself and repeats through a significant number of cycles. The canonical explanation of this phenomenon, commonly shown in many high school and college physics classes, is simply the conservation of momentum and kinetic energy m in elastic collisions, these quantities being exchanged between the first and fifth balls through infinitesimal elastic deformations, similar to sound waves. Sometimes Newton's third law of action and reaction is evoked in the explanation.
mv
1
2
2
v
So we have a neat experiment with a simple theoretical explanation, which satisfies the majority of physicists. However, several recent references, cited herein, note that, upon closer observation, the middle three balls do, in fact, oscillate very slightly. This can be attributed to the imperfect elasticity of the impacts, together with viscoelastic dissipation and possibly air resistance.
No consensus has yet been achieved for a rigorous solution of this problem. In fact, several videos of Newton's cradle displayed on the internet (YouTube) show small variations in the behavior of the swinging balls, depending evidently on small differences in construction and materials. In all cases, the preponderant tendency appears to be small-amplitude oscillations of the middle three balls, more or less in sync with the motion of the first and fifth balls.
In this Demonstration, we propose an empirical model containing a parameter , to estimate the fraction of kinetic energy transformed into elastic deformation in each collision along with the concomitant dissipation of energy. The canonical behavior is obtained in the limiting case, . The balls are assumed to be of unit diameter with their centers at equilibrium at =n, .
ξ
ξ
0
x
n
n=0,1,2,3,4