Algebraic Solution of the Plemelj Triangle Construction Problem

​
h
c
0.5
α - β (radians)
0.3
α
β
α - β
0.957259
0.657259
0.3
This problem asks for the construction of a triangle
ABC
with ruler and compass given the length of the base
AB=c
(for simplicity, let
c=1
), the length of the altitude
h
c
from
C
to
AB
and the difference
α-β
of the angles
α=∠BAC
and
β=∠ABC
. The problem was posed to Plemelj by his math teacher, Borstner, when Plemelj was about 16 years old.
Plemelj solved the problem using trigonometry, and later found a geometric construction. The starting point was the identity
h
c
(cotα+cotβ)=c
, from which he derived the equation
2
h
c
sinγ-ccosγ=ccos(α-β)
. This equation can be transformed by substituting
cos(γ)=
1-
2
sin
γ
. Eliminating the square root gives a quadratic equation for
sinγ
, which means that it and
γ
can be constructed by using a straight edge and a compass.
Using the formula
sinγ=c/2R
, where
R
is the radius of the circumscribed circle, gives a quadratic equation for
R
.
To construct the triangle, first draw a vertical straight line
CD
of length
h
c
and a horizontal line through
D
. Then draw line
CE
so that
∠ECD=1/2(α-β)
. If
CD
is the altitude on
c
, then
CE
is the bisector of angle
γ
. Draw the straight line
CB
so that
∠DCE=1/2γ
. Then measure out a distance
c
from
B
on the horizontal line to find
A
.
To use
R
in the construction, we must know that the angle
∠DCS
between the altitude and the line
CS
from
C
to the center of the circumscribed circle of the triangle is
α-β
.
So on the line through
C
that has the angle
α-β
with
CD
, measure out a distance
R
to find the point
S
. Then draw a circumscribed circle
σ
. Points
A
and
B
are intersections of
σ
by the horizontal line through
D
.
The solutions can be checked to verify that they give the same result.

Details

Plemelj's most original contribution is the elementary solution he provided for the Riemann–Hilbert problem about the existence of a differential equation with given monodromy group[1, 2]. Plemelj's first solution of the triangle construction problem was given in[2]. We take his trigonometry explanation from[3, pp. 191]. He also noted that he had made nine original solutions of the problem, and that he had also known about two textbook solutions.
The text in[3] is from a talk Plemelj gave in 1949 at the First Congress of Yugoslav Societies of Mathematicians, Physicists and Astronomers in Bled (Slovenia). The talk was published in 1951 in Belgrade in the proceedings of the congress.
Two different solutions of the problem are published in[4], and one in[5].

References

[1] Wikipedia. "Josip Plemelj." (May 31, 2017) en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Josip_Plemelj.
[2] J. J. O'Connor and E. F. Robertson. "Josip Plemelj." MacTutor. www-history.mcs.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Plemelj.html.
[3] J. Plemelj, Iz mojega življenja in dela (From My Life and Work), Obzornik mat. fiz., 39, 1992 pp. 188–192.
[4] D. S. Modic, Triangles, Constructions, Algebraic Solutions (in Slovenian), Ljubljana: Math Publishers, 2009.
[5] I. Pucelj, "Plemelj's Triangle and Fixed Points of Transformations" (in Slovenian), Obzornik mat. fiz., 62(1), 2015 pp. 12–14.

External Links

Triangle (Wolfram MathWorld)

Permanent Citation

Izidor Hafner
​
​"Algebraic Solution of the Plemelj Triangle Construction Problem"​
​http://demonstrations.wolfram.com/AlgebraicSolutionOfThePlemeljTriangleConstructionProblem/​
​Wolfram Demonstrations Project​
​Published: June 1, 2017